• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Seneca Farms: A Southern American Delight with Fried Chicken & Homemade Ice Cream

At Seneca Farms, nestled in the heart of Penn Yan, NY, southern charm and culinary passion unite. Renowned for its irresistible fried chicken, the eatery invites guests to embrace a cozy atmosphere, whether dining in or enjoying the drive-thru. The extensive menu boasts a variety of sandwiches and specialty sundaes, complemented by delightful soft custard creations. With amenities such as outdoor seating, catering services, and a welcoming environment for families and pets alike, Seneca Farms stands out as a beloved destination. It's not just a meal; it's an experience filled with friendly service and nostalgic flavors that will keep you coming back.

Seneca Farms at a glance

  • Address 2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
  • Phone (315) 536-4066
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Fried chicken takeaway , Hamburger restaurant .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Seneca Farms: Reviews & Ratings

Mark Towne
5

Fast, efficient and friendly service. Fantastic ice cream they make themselves. My wife said their fried chicken is outstanding! I had a seafood trio meal with fried fish, clams and shrimp. Came hot and delicious. I really enjoy fried clams, but it's hard to find someplace that does them right - THIS IS THE PLACE! Oh, and don't forget their corn fritters which are nothing short of amazing.

JJ Bechtel
5

Delicious homemade ice cream! The place was hopping on a Thursday night! Service was fast! The selection of flavors was expansive! The cookies and cream and butter pecan and salted caramel were delicious!! Outdoor seating is great! A slice out of pure Americana! This is what I think of when looking for a small hometown Summer evening ice cream shop!

Julia Aitziane
5

The ice cream was decadent and fresh tasting. They had vegan options. I highly recommend two or three visits. We didn't eat the food but there were lines out the door!

Credible Source, Inc
5

I never thought of a corn fritter in a sundae. That is literally the best thing I have ever tasted! Service was friendly but that sundae is to die for! One of us got fried chicken and it was the best fried chicken we've had! Highly recommend. Not greasy, great flavor in the breading. Pieces were of ample size. Would definitely have again!

TJG
4

Good fried chicken in the back. Ice cream out front. Good mac salad. Lots of parking. Inside seating and outside seating under a tent.

Greg Scott
5

My wife and I have been doing some sight- seeing in the Finger Lakes region (visiting from Texas) and just happen to drive by and the white and red exterior caught our attention. We turned around to go back and check them out (5/25/25, their 75th anniversary). The parking area was very busy as well as the dining room and the enclosed pavilion out back. At first we walked into the ice cream shop in front but then we went to the back for the dining room. The lady at the counter asked about taking out order and we exlained that about the curb appeal of the restaurant from the road got our attention and we had never been there. She was very pleasant and helpful with describing what they had to offer. We decided to get a 4-pc meal and share just to try it out. I do not regularly eat fried chicken (on the bones) but we after taking a few bites, we just looked at each other amazed at the taste of the chicken and how well the chicken was cooked. Today, we made a special trip to to drive back here from Bath, NY, just to have lunch. We ordered the Family Meal just so we could take some with us to eat later. Hitting the ice cream shop next specifically for the Banana Split, which uses the 3-flavors of ice cream like I remember a a kid (in Illinois). Most places we have seen around the country (including DQ) uses all vanilla ice cream with the jar flavored toppings. This place is as good as it gets for great dining in the Finger Lakes area. Enjoy!

G W
5

Super cute spot to grab some ice cream and enjoy the great vibes! It didn’t take long at all to get our order in, and the ice cream was delicious. We also checked out the diner next door, and it was just as charming—the staff at both places were super friendly and the service was quick. Definitely would return!

Tilly Lo
5

20250521 Came here to get some fried chicken for my finicky pup. The ladies working here are very nice. I ordered a garden salad and 3 pieces dark meat with Mac and cheese and beans. The garden salad was ok. It only has iceberg lettuce, cucumber slices, tomatoes and some cheese. I don't recommend it unless you really need some veggies. It would have been better if they add an egg. The fried chicken was delicious! My pup loved it! The corn fritters were amazing!! The best I ever had! I would definitely come back for their dried chicken. The entrance to the diner is on the side where the parking lot is. Facing the street is the entrance to the ice cream shop. The employee working in the ice cream shop was soooo nice and informative. I didn't get ice cream because my pup is diabetic... no more ice cream for her, and I can't eat it in front of her. The ice cream products look delicious! They have ice cream cakes and sandwiches too. He mentioned they have a gift shop across the street.

Location

  • Seneca Farms
    Seneca Farms
    2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527 Hotline: (315) 536-4066

Welcome to the world of Seneca Farms, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Penn Yan, NY. This Southern American eatery has established itself as a beloved destination for locals and travelers alike, combining classic comfort food with a delightful ice cream experience. Whether you choose to dine in or take your meal on the go, Seneca Farms promises a warm, friendly atmosphere paired with an array of delicious offerings.

Located at 2485 NY-54A, Seneca Farms is not just a restaurant; it's a culinary haven where every detail is carefully crafted to ensure a memorable dining experience. Known primarily for their fried chicken, they serve up a variety of mouth-watering sides including mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, and onion rings. Patrons rave about the flavors, with many suggesting the dark meat combo as a must-try. The creation of a perfect meal is complemented by the option to enjoy a variety of soft custard flavors, including peanut butter and dark chocolate, as well as an impressive rotation of seasonal homemade hard ice cream flavors!

One of the highlights of Seneca Farms is its commitment to accessibility and convenience. The premises are wheelchair accessible, featuring ADA-compliant restrooms and ample outdoor seating. Families and large groups are welcome, making it an ideal choice for casual gatherings. Customers can enjoy their meals al fresco on the heated outdoor patio or opt for quick service through the drive-thru. With QR code menus available and options for catering, every aspect of the dining experience is designed for ease and enjoyment.

  • Highlight: Fried Chicken - Tender, flavorful, and simply irresistible.
  • Ice Cream Variety - Over 20 flavors to excite your taste buds.
  • Friendly Staff - Consistently praised for their excellent service.
  • Outdoor Seating - A perfect spot to enjoy your meal in the fresh air.

As you can tell from numerous satisfied reviews, people have a special place in their hearts for this restaurant. G. Brian M. mentions that the fried chicken at Seneca Farms is a staple he cannot resist, while Jeremy B. highlights the ease of pick-up orders through a loudspeaker system, which speaks volumes about the thoughtful customer service. There’s a palpable sense of nostalgia and joy that comes with each visit, especially when savoring their delectable ice creams. The quaint charm of Seneca Farms and its blend of comfort food and perfectly crafted desserts deliver a delightful experience that keeps diners coming back for more.

In conclusion, whether you're stopping by for lunch, dinner, or a sweet treat, Seneca Farms stands out as a beacon of Southern American cuisine in the area. Your taste buds won’t know what hit them, and your heart will surely thank you for this delightful culinary adventure. Don’t forget to check out their seasonal offerings and perhaps take home a souvenir from the adjacent shop. Next time you’re in the neighborhood, be sure to make a pit stop at Seneca Farms—you won't regret it!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has drive-through
    • In-store pick-up for online orders
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards